BONUS: ALDS Game 1 Reaction (10/3/26)

The Yankees had the pitching. They had the opportunity. They just couldn't hit.

Game 1 of the ALDS ends with Tampa Bay winning 1–0, and Yankees fans are left wondering how an offense with this much talent managed to produce so little.

Chris and AJ react immediately after the loss, breaking down a frustrating night that featured 12 Yankees strikeouts, almost no quality at-bats, and an offense that couldn't capitalize on Gerrit Cole's strong start. Cole allowed just one run over five innings, while the bullpen kept Tampa Bay from adding to its lead.

They also revisit Austin Wells' decision to try for third base after finally breaking through with the Yankees' first hit, debate whether Giancarlo Stanton should have been on the postseason roster, and question some of the Yankees' late-game decisions—including the bunt attempt by Ryan McMahon.

But the conversation isn't entirely negative. The Yankees still have their biggest advantage: pitching. Chris and AJ look ahead to Game 2, discuss the expected pitching matchup, and try to figure out whether the Yankees can turn things around before returning home.

Because one loss in a playoff series doesn't decide anything.

But the offense needs to wake up.

Topics Discussed

• Why the Yankees' offensive approach was so frustrating in Game 1
• How 12 strikeouts contributed to an almost completely stagnant offense
• Why Gerrit Cole's performance wasn't the problem
• What went wrong on Austin Wells' attempt to reach third base
• Why the decision to bring Giancarlo Stanton into the game was questioned
• Why the McMahon bunt attempt didn't make sense to Chris and AJ
• How the Yankees' pitching gives them a path back into the series
• Why Game 2 could completely change the complexion of the ALDS
• Why one 1–0 loss shouldn't cause Yankees fans to panic
• What the Yankees need from their offense moving forward

Bullpen Q&A ☎️

You have opinions just like we do, so we want to hear from you!

1. Send voicemail http://chasefor28.com/voicemail
2. Email us: feedback@chasefor28.com
3. Connect on X: @chasefor28pod
4. Connect on Instagram: @chasefor28pod

Merch 👕

1. Podcast and Select Player Shirts

SeatGeek 🎟

Check out SeatGeek - the easiest way to buy tickets for sports, concerts, and more. Visit chasefor28.com/seatgeek and use promo code 'CHASEFOR28' at checkout to get $20 off your first purchase.

Affiliate Disclosure: Some links may be affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thanks for your support!